Last modified: 7:58 AM Saturday, 14 January 2017

Unjustly maligned

‘Guilt by association’ always unsound reasoning

My thanks to Glenn Greenwald, and my apologies to my readers. In reviewing the Nation commentary on the TSA backlash, I fell down journalistically: I looked only at the broad picture, and failed to take the authors to task for insidiously calumniating a private citizen, John Tyner, without a trace of evidence that he had done anything wrong other than being on the wrong “team” as a self-identified libertarian.

John Tyner

John Tyner: a person, not a symbol.
[ Image Source ]

I could excuse this by telling you I had only 4,500 characters in which to assess a rather complicated story, but the fact is, I was insufficiently vigilant and failed to observe and denounce an odious act of journalistic malpractice. Therefore I will now state this forthrightly: That some of the “whistleblowers” against the TSA are trying to manufacture public outrage for private gain does not mean that all of them are.

As far as I know and can learn from available material on the web, John Tyner is exactly what he says he is: a private but civic-minded citizen who objects to the Morton’s Fork offered by the TSA. He has done nothing wrong, and the insinuations made against him are all based on guilt by association, a logical fallacy and a sin against the canons of journalistic integrity.

Originally published as a review of a article rebuking The Nation for its reporting on the TSA backlash.

Peace, liberty, unity, justice, equality
Home Economy Government Mammonolatry Pathocracy Religion Science Society The Record The Struggle WikiLeaks World Events